Market Commentary – September 2025

Monthly Recap

Corporate Profitability & Valuation Considerations

“Magnificent 7” Excellence Drives Market Leadership

The “Magnificent 7” technology giants demonstrated exceptional performance, with 100% beating estimates compared to 81% for the broader market. These companies exceeded earnings estimates by 10.5% versus 7.7% for all S&P 500 companies, delivering actual earnings growth of 26.6% for Q2. Four companies – NVIDIA, Amazon.com, Meta Platforms, and Microsoft – ranked among the top six contributors to overall S&P 500 earnings growth, underscoring their outsized market influence.

Sustained Profitability with Valuation Concerns

Corporate profitability remained robust with the S&P 500 reporting its fifth consecutive quarter with net profit margins above 12%, reaching 12.8% in Q2. This reflects management teams’ ability to maintain pricing power while navigating cost pressures.

However, this strong fundamental performance comes alongside elevated valuations. The forward 12-month price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio stands at 22.4, significantly above both the 5-year average of 19.9 and 10-year average of 18.5. Since Q2’s end, index prices increased 4.8% while forward earnings estimates rose just 3.5%, indicating multiple expansion rather than earnings growth has driven recent gains. The trailing 12-month P/E ratio of 27.9 sits well above historical averages of 25.0 (5-year) and 22.6 (10-year).

Despite robust Q2 results and the remarkable market recovery, stretched valuations suggest investors may need to temper return expectations as markets navigate the tension between strong corporate fundamentals and elevated equity valuations.

Topic of the Month: Expected Interest Rate Cuts in September 2025

Expected GDP Growth Impact

While rate cuts typically stimulate Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth through lower borrowing costs, increased investment, and enhanced consumer spending, current economic conditions suggest their impact may be more muted than usual. The US economy demonstrated unexpected resilience in Q2 2025, with revised data showing 3.3% annualized growth compared to initial estimates of 3.0%, rebounding sharply from Q1’s 0.5% contraction. This outperformance, driven by robust consumer spending, suggests earlier concerns about tariff impacts may have been “misplaced,” though the underlying momentum remains fragile due to pre-tariff stockpiling effects that artificially boosted activity and could be a drag on third and fourth quarter demand.

However, emerging economic headwinds are already dampening the outlook. Slowing job growth signals the economy could stagnate in Q3, strengthening the case for monetary easing despite recent strong performance. The Federal Reserve has accordingly revised its 2025 GDP growth forecast downward to 1.4%, while private economists project growth between 1.4% and 2.5%. This cautious outlook reflects ongoing challenges from tariff policies, trade uncertainty, and elevated debt levels that could limit the effectiveness of traditional monetary stimulus.

Most economists expect rate cuts to provide more meaningful growth support in late 2025 and into 2026, as financial conditions improve and tariff-related disruptions stabilize.

Stock Market Impact

The S&P 500 has reached all-time highs, reflecting what analysts describe as a “bull market alive and well” that would require a meaningful catalyst like a recession to derail it. This strength has been underpinned by robust Q2 corporate earnings, with the S&P 500 delivering 10.5% earnings per share (EPS) growth that exceeded lowered expectations, though companies missing estimates have faced particularly harsh market reactions. However, the market’s extreme reliance on a few large growth stocks, particularly the “Magnificent 7” tech companies, has reached unprecedented levels of concentration that poses structural risks, as historical dominance provides no guarantee of future performance.

Rate cuts create multiple favorable transmission mechanisms for equity markets that extend well beyond simple valuation effects. Lower borrowing costs directly reduce corporate financing expenses while simultaneously improving consumer purchasing power, creating a dual boost to corporate revenues. Additionally, the wealth effect generated by rising asset prices encourages increased spending and investment, establishing positive feedback loops that can sustain economic momentum and further support market gains across sectors.

Technology Sector Leadership: Technology companies benefit most significantly because their valuations depend heavily on future cash flows that are years away. When the Federal Reserve cuts rates, the discount rate used to calculate present value of these future earnings declines, making distant profits worth more today. This mathematical relationship particularly benefits companies whose current profits are modest relative to expected future growth. Additionally, lower rates improve access to capital for research, development, and acquisitions while encouraging investors to rotate from low-yielding bonds into growth assets.

The sector’s exceptional fundamentals support this favorable rate environment positioning. Q2 2025 demonstrated technology’s earnings power with the Information Technology sector delivering 22.6% year-over-year earnings growth, while all six technology sub-industries reported positive growth led by Semiconductors & Semiconductor Equipment at 37%.

Sector Performance Dynamics: Rate cuts create distinct winners across market sectors through various transmission mechanisms. Real estate and construction companies benefit most directly from reduced mortgage rates and cheaper project financing, with homebuilders, real estate investment trusts (REITs), and mortgage lenders experiencing immediate demand improvements as housing affordability increases. Financial institutions face more complex dynamics – while lower rates may initially compress net interest margins, banks typically benefit from increased lending volume and yield curve steepening effects that ultimately support profitability.

Consumer sectors respond positively but through different pathways. Defensive Consumer Staples provide stability and consistent returns during periods of uncertainty, while Consumer Discretionary companies gain from improved financing conditions for major purchases such as automobiles and appliances. The psychological confidence effect from monetary easing often translates into increased spending on non-essential items, further benefiting discretionary retailers and service providers.

Market capitalization and investment style significantly influence rate cut responses. Smaller companies typically outperform larger peers due to their greater sensitivity to domestic economic conditions and higher reliance on external financing. Many small-caps benefit immediately from reduced costs on floating-rate debt, while their limited capital market access makes them disproportionate beneficiaries of easier credit conditions. Similarly, growth stocks demonstrate superior performance because their valuations depend heavily on discount rates applied to future earnings, whereas value stocks – deriving more worth from current cash flows and tangible assets – show less dramatic initial responses but may eventually benefit if rate cuts successfully stimulate broader economic growth without triggering inflation concerns.

Alternative Assets Impact

Gold: Gold has established itself as the “ultimate policy hedge”. As of August 29, gold was at $3,447.95 per ounce, up more than 30% in 2025 and approximately 112% from its late 2022 low. The metal’s appeal is amplified by dollar weakness, its inflation hedge properties, and growing demand as protection against domestic volatility and political institutional pressures. Central bank accumulation and rebuilding exchange traded fund (ETF) holdings provide structural support with further upside potential.

Rate cuts enhance gold’s attractiveness by reducing the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding assets compared to interest-bearing alternatives. When real interest rates decline or turn negative, gold becomes a compelling store of value, while accompanying dollar weakness makes it more affordable for international buyers. This monetary policy transmission works alongside geopolitical uncertainties and central bank buying to provide support independent of traditional market dynamics.

Cryptocurrency: Rate cuts create multiple bullish catalysts for digital assets. Lower interest rates weaken the dollar, which historically benefits cryptocurrencies as alternative stores of value. Increased liquidity from monetary easing flows into risk assets, with crypto markets benefiting from their accessibility and continuous trading. The decentralized finance ecosystem particularly gains from lower capital opportunity costs and increased venture funding into blockchain innovation. However, crypto’s high correlation with traditional risk assets means performance depends on whether cuts are seen as growth-supportive or crisis-responsive.

US Dollar: The dollar faces downward pressure from expected rate cuts, with the Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index down 8.31% year-to-date. Rate cuts reduce the currency’s yield advantage relative to other major currencies, encouraging capital outflows as investors seek higher returns elsewhere – an effect amplified when other central banks maintain higher rates while the Fed cuts. The dollar also confronts structural headwinds from its diminishing global role, as central banks increasingly allocate reserves to gold at the expense of dollar holdings, a trend that could accelerate with ongoing de-dollarization efforts. Dollar weakness could be amplified if a global consensus arises that the Fed was pushed into lowering rates by the administration.

However, the dollar’s decline isn’t guaranteed. Its safe-haven status can offset yield-based weakness if rate cuts are perceived as responses to serious economic stress rather than preemptive policy moves. Additionally, hawkish forward guidance or signs of US economic resilience relative to other regions could limit dollar losses. The currency also benefits when improved global risk appetite drives investors away from domestic safe-haven assets toward international growth opportunities, though this dynamic depends heavily on the context and perceived motivation behind Fed policy actions.

Trade and Consumer Impact

Rate cuts and the resulting dollar weakness create mixed trade effects that take time to fully materialize. US export competitiveness improves as dollar depreciation makes American goods cheaper internationally, benefiting manufacturing, agriculture, and technology services sectors. The trade balance typically improves through increased exports and reduced imports, though these effects require 6-18 months to fully develop. However, higher import prices simultaneously create inflationary pressures, particularly impacting technology manufacturing, automotive, and retail sectors that depend heavily on foreign components, though energy import vulnerability has been reduced by increased domestic production.

Consumer behavior responds more immediately to lower interest rates through enhanced purchasing power for major expenditures. Cheaper financing boosts demand for housing, automobiles, and appliances, while mortgage refinancing surges provide cash flow improvements that sustain broader spending increases. The impact varies demographically and regionally, with younger consumers showing the strongest response to rate cuts, while regional differences reflect varying exposure to variable versus fixed-rate debt structures.

Bond Market Response

The bond market rallied following Powell’s dovish signals, with short-term yields falling and the yield curve steepening to levels not seen in years. Current Treasury yields reflect this dynamic, with the 2-year at 3.64% (up three basis points), the 10-year at 4.21% (down two basis points), and the 30-year at 4.88% (down four basis points). However, long-term yields remain stubbornly elevated due to concerns about tariff-driven inflation, the expanding budget deficit, and risks of the Fed cutting rates too aggressively. Meanwhile, US junk bond yields have plunged to a 40-month low, fueled by rate cut expectations, strong corporate earnings, and relatively weak labor data.

The steepening yield curve benefits multiple market segments as short rates fall faster than long rates, widening spreads and boosting bank profitability while typically signaling positive economic expectations that support risk assets. Short-term Treasuries show the strongest price gains due to their direct Fed policy linkage, with 2-year yields potentially dropping 10-20 basis points, while 10-year yields face more modest declines based on long-term growth expectations. Corporate bonds stand to benefit significantly, with investment-grade issues gaining from both declining Treasury yields and tightening credit spreads, while high-yield bonds may deliver exceptional returns if economic conditions remain stable, though careful credit analysis becomes increasingly crucial in this environment.

Post-Meeting Guidance and Investment Positioning

Market focus will shift to Fed communications about future policy direction, with several key signals determining asset performance. Clear indication of a sustained easing cycle rather than a “one-and-done” approach would fuel continued rallies across growth stocks, bonds, and rate-sensitive assets while extending dollar weakness. The Fed’s emphasis between labor market support versus inflation vigilance will also prove crucial – employment-focused guidance suggests more aggressive easing that benefits interest-rate sensitive sectors, while continued inflation concerns imply a more measured approach potentially supporting financial stocks. Updated economic projections for growth, unemployment, and inflation will provide quantitative policy insights, with lower rate projections versus market expectations fueling asset rallies and higher projections potentially triggering disappointment.

Post-meeting communications emphasizing continued data dependence will make employment reports, CPI releases, and regional indicators particularly market-sensitive going forward. Strong economic data might reduce expectations for additional cuts and support dollar strength, while weak data would reinforce accommodation expectations and benefit rate-sensitive assets. This dynamic creates ongoing positioning opportunities, with optimal first-month allocation including overweighted growth and technology stocks, large-cap quality names, and defensive sectors like Healthcare and Consumer Staples, while fixed income positioning should favor intermediate-duration Treasuries and high-quality corporate bonds.

Investors should prepare for elevated volatility following rate cuts, with the Volatility Index (VIX) potentially doubling from pre-cut levels as historical patterns show heightened market swings for several weeks before stabilization. This environment requires disciplined position sizing and diversification strategies, as the interaction between Fed guidance and subsequent economic data will ultimately determine market direction through the rest of 2025. Success will depend on maintaining flexible, data-responsive investment approaches that can adapt to evolving monetary policy signals and economic conditions.

The current economic landscape presents a paradox of surface-level strength masking deeper structural uncertainties. While the S&P 500 has achieved record highs and Q2 data revealed unexpected economic resilience, the underlying environment remains fraught with challenges from disruptive trade policies, unprecedented political pressure on Federal Reserve independence, and persistent inflation driven primarily by services sector price increases. This complex backdrop has created intricate cross-currents across financial markets, leaving investors heavily dependent on upcoming data releases – particularly the Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index and August employment report – to provide clarity on both economic trajectory and Fed policy direction through the remainder of 2025.

Conclusion

This material is distributed by James Investment Research, Inc. and is for information purposes only. No part of this document may be reproduced in any manner without the written permission of James Investment. It is provided with the understanding that no fiduciary relationship exists because of this report. Opinions expressed in this report are the opinions of James Investment and are subject to change without notice. James Investment assumes no liability for the interpretation or use of this report. Investment conclusions and strategies suggested in this report may not be suitable for all investors and consultation with a qualified investment advisor is recommended prior to executing any investment strategy. Past performance is not indicative of future results. All rights reserved. Copyright © 2025 James Investment.